Across the United States, only a handful of states continue to recognize common law marriage. This type of informal marriage without a license or ceremony was once more widespread in America, but today only permitted in several states.
Utah is one of the states that still acknowledges couples in common law marriages if they meet certain requirements. Understanding Utah’s laws and the rights of common law spouses is essential for anyone in this type of relationship.
This guide will provide a comprehensive overview of common law marriage in Utah, including:
- Defining common law marriage and how it differs from ceremonial marriage
- Examining the legal framework and criteria for recognition
- Benefits, rights, and implications under state law
- The process for establishing and ending a common law marriage
- Strategies for documenting the relationship
- How common law marriage in Utah compares to other states
- Notable legal cases and potential challenges
- Expert advice for navigating common law status
- Resources and support available
Whether you are considering entering a common law marriage or are already in one, this guide can help you make informed choices and protect your rights under the law. Let’s get started!
Contents
- 1 Understanding Common Law Marriage
- 2 Legal Framework for Common Law Marriage in Utah
- 3 Benefits and Legal Implications
- 4 Establishing a Common Law Marriage in Utah
- 5 Common Law Marriage and Children
- 6 Dissolving a Common Law Marriage
- 7 Protecting Your Rights in a Common Law Marriage
- 8 Utah and Common Law Marriage in Other States
- 9 Legal Challenges and Case Studies
- 10 Expert Insights on Common Law Marriage
- 11 Transitioning to a Ceremonial Marriage
- 12 Frequently Asked Questions
- 13 Conclusion: Moving Forward Mindfully
Understanding Common Law Marriage
What is Common Law Marriage?
A common law marriage is a legally recognized marriage between two consenting adults who have not obtained a marriage license or had a formal ceremony. It is based on common law, or the legal precedents and traditions that develop through court decisions rather than statutes.
Some key attributes of common law marriage include:
- No requirement for government documentation
- Automatic legal status after meeting requirements
- Spouses have same rights and duties
- Recognized for purposes like inheritance and tax filing
Common law marriage is an alternative to formal or ceremonial marriage sanctioned by the state through licenses and registration.
How Common Law Marriage Differs from Ceremonial Marriage
While common law spouses enjoy the same rights and privileges under state law, there are some key differences from ceremonial marriage:
| Ceremonial Marriage | Common Law Marriage |
|---|---|
| Legal status begins at marriage date | Legal status begins when requirements met |
| Requires license and ceremony | No license or ceremony required |
| Formal registration with government | No registration, prove existence in court |
| Ends through divorce | Ends by court order or death |
History of Common Law Marriage in Utah
Common law marriage has a long history and tradition in Utah stemming from the state’s pioneer beginnings. With limited government and infrastructure in territorial Utah, informal marriages were common and valid.
The tradition continued even after statehood in 1896. Utah legally recognized common law marriages until 1987 when the statute was repealed, invalidating any new common law marriages after that date.
However, common law marriages established in Utah prior to 1987 are still considered valid under the law. The state also recognizes common law marriages properly entered in other states.
Legal Framework for Common Law Marriage in Utah
While Utah no longer allows the creation of new common law marriages within the state, the legal structure remains in place for continuing recognition of properly established common law marriages.
Utah Code Section 30-1-4.5
In 1987, the Utah State Legislature repealed the statute authorizing common law marriage. This is codified in Utah Code §30-1-4.5 which states:
“The determination or establishment of a marriage under this section must occur during the relationship described in Subsection (1), or within one year following the termination of that relationship. Evidence of a marriage recognizable under this section may be manifested in any form, and may be proved under the same general rules of evidence as facts in other cases.”
This provides for ongoing recognition of Utah common law marriages established prior to 1987, while prohibiting new common law marriages from being formed.
Essential Criteria for Recognition
Under Utah law, the following criteria must be met for a court to recognize a common law marriage:
- The relationship began before 1987 in Utah
- The couple cohabitated and held themselves out to be married
- The parties were legally competent to enter a marriage
- The marriage was non-polygamous
Meeting these standards provides the basis for recognition of marital rights.
Process for Legal Acknowledgment
There is no automatic government registration of common law marriages. The validity and existence of the relationship must be proven in court if legally challenged or subject to judicial proceedings.
If needed, couples can initiate legal action to formally establish the common law marriage through the courts for purposes of documentation.
Benefits and Legal Implications
Under Utah law, those in properly established common law marriages enjoy broad rights and recognition, even without formal licensing. These include:
- Joint tax filing status and exemptions
- Inheritance and estate rights
- Shared property rights
- Spousal benefits and protections
- Child custody, support, and visitation
However, with the informal nature of common law marriage comes greater vulnerability without documented proof. Consult a lawyer to understand how to secure your rights.
Establishing a Common Law Marriage in Utah
For those in longstanding relationships seeking retroactive recognition of a Utah common law marriage predating 1987, there is a process for pursuing legal acknowledgment.
Applying for Declaration
You can petition a Utah court for a formal Declaration of Marriage to validate your common law status. This requires submitting an application to the district court outlining evidence the relationship meets the legal criteria.
Evidence Needed
Vital records that may support a common law marriage include:
- Joint tax returns or property records
- Bank accounts or bills in both names
- Personal letters or correspondence
- Shared insurance policies or wills
- Children’s birth certificates
- Affidavits from family/friends
The more documentation you have evidencing the relationship, the stronger your case.
Common Law Marriage and Children
Common law spouses in Utah have the same rights and responsibilities regarding children as legally married couples.
Child Custody and Support
If a common law marriage ends, child custody and support are determined based on the best interests of the child, just like a traditional divorce. Courts will recognize the status when issuing orders.
Birth Records
Children born to common law spouses can be given their father’s surname if paternity is acknowledged, even without marriage documentation.
Dissolving a Common Law Marriage
Under Utah law, a common law marriage is dissolved in the same manner as a ceremonial marriage – through a court order. This requires a formal divorce proceeding.
Some key considerations in ending a common law marriage include:
- Establishing status and date of marriage
- Determining community property for division
- Co-parenting agreements and child support
- Spousal maintenance and alimony
Unlike a registered marriage, couples must first prove the existence of the common law marriage to the court’s satisfaction.
Protecting Your Rights in a Common Law Marriage
Because common law marriage lacks the standard documentation of a licensed union, it is critical for couples to take steps to safeguard their rights.
Creating Agreements
Formalize understandings between spouses with respect to property and finances through written agreements. These help avoid uncertainty down the road.
Documenting Status
Whenever possible, include your spouse and marital status on applications, tax forms, deeds, wills and other instruments to leave a paper trail evidencing the marriage.
| Type | Examples |
|---|---|
| Legal | Wills, power of attorney, living wills |
| Financial | Joint bank accounts, credit cards, tax returns |
| Personal | Insurance policies, retirement plans, medical decisions |
| Property | Home titles, rental agreements, car registrations |
Utah and Common Law Marriage in Other States
The recognition of common law marriages across state lines can create complications around conflicting state laws. Here are some key considerations:
Comparison to Other States
Currently only nine states permit common law marriage, with variations in qualifications:
- Alabama, Colorado, Iowa, Kansas, Montana, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Texas, Utah*
*Utah recognizes pre-1987 common law marriages only
Recognition of Utah Common Law Marriages
A Utah common law marriage from before 1987 will be recognized as valid in other states following legal precedents around interstate marriage recognition.
However, couples should still validate the marriage through a Utah court proceeding when relocating to strengthen protections. Consult an attorney on your options.
Legal Challenges and Case Studies
Over the years, Utah courts have weighed in on various aspects of common law marriage through key rulings that help define parameters.
Major Precedents:
- Whyte v. Blair (Utah Supreme Court, 1951) – Outlined criteria for showing common law marriage
- Matthews v. Matthews (Utah Court of Appeals, 1990) – Confirmed pre-1987 cutoff date
- Singh v. Singh (Utah Court of Appeals, 2003) – Reiterated ongoing recognition of pre-1987 common law marriages
These and other cases help shape how courts view common law marriage questions today. Real-world examples provide insight into handling legal challenges.
Expert Insights on Common Law Marriage
Navigating informal marriage relationships can be complex, so guidance from professionals is highly recommended.
Legal Pitfalls to Avoid
- Failing to document the marriage in writing
- Not having evidence to prove marital status
- Moving between states without validating marriage
- Not understanding rights at death or dissolution
Tips to Protect Yourself
- Consult a lawyer about formalizing your status
- Maintain records showing existence of marriage
- Seek court validation before relocating
- Execute wills and other end-of-life documents
Take steps to avoid uncertainty! An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.
Transitioning to a Ceremonial Marriage
Common law spouses may opt to formalize their relationship by obtaining a marriage license and having a ceremony. Reasons include more concrete proof of marital status as well as the symbolic significance for many couples of declaring wedding vows.
Converting Your Status
The process involves applying for a license through the county clerk and having an officiant perform a marriage ceremony. Follow the standard procedures used for any civil marriage.
Things to Consider
- Updating existing documents like wills and insurance policies to reflect formal married status
- Notifying government agencies such as Social Security of new marriage date
- Celebrating your union! Have a ceremony and reception to celebrate with family and friends
Frequently Asked Questions
Below are answers to some of the most common questions around recognition of common law marriage in Utah.
Does Utah recognize new common law marriages formed today?
No, Utah has not permitted the creation of new common law marriages since 1987. Only those established in Utah prior to that year are still valid.
Do we need to register our common law marriage formally?
There is no registration or record-keeping by the state. However, obtaining a court order declaring your status is recommended for legal documentation purposes.
What if we move between states? Is our common law marriage still valid?
As long as the marriage was properly formed in Utah or another state permitting common law marriage at that time, it will be recognized. However, follow up with courts or an attorney when relocating to ensure protections in your new state.
What steps can we take to document our marriage?
File joint tax returns, share bank accounts and credit cards, register assets in both names, name your partner on insurance and wills, and maintain records like letters addressing you as spouses.
How do we end a common law marriage?
Common law marriages must be dissolved through the same court procedures as ceremonial marriages. You cannot simply walk away. Get guidance on filing for divorce.
Conclusion: Moving Forward Mindfully
We hope this overview has provided useful insights and guidance on common law marriage recognition in Utah. Above all, be sure to:
- Seek legal counsel to understand your rights and protections fully
- Gather documentation establishing you as a married couple
- Make informed choices as your relationship evolves
Common law marriages may lack the formality of ceremonial unions, but with foresight and diligence you can still enjoy legitimacy, security, and peace of mind. Wishing you all the best on your path forward!
Scott A. Bentley Attorney at Law in McHenry, IL is a debt relief and personal injury attorney dedicated to helping people in their time of need. He can assist in filing bankruptcy under the bankruptcy code or work with you through a personal injury case. His more than 25 years of experience provide him with the insight and knowledge you need when contending with difficult legal issues. Scott Bentley bankruptcy services stop: Creditor harassment, Lawsuits, Garnishments, Foreclosures, Repossessions, By filing for chapter 7 or 13 bankruptcy with Scott Bentley, you’ll also be able to create personal reorganization plans that serve to resolve individual bankruptcy issues. He and his staff are committed to providing you with dignified service and the respect you deserve. Just because you owe someone or some company money doesn’t mean you forfeit your rights. With Mr. Bentley you can be sure you will receive personalized attention and aggressive legal representation. The firm is proud to